Talk:A Phoenix Saved (Eight of Jokers)/@comment-31439598-20170310003238

Some more observations and ramblings on this one. If this was a phrase from a pre-existing work, I would have expected there to be more shorter length words in the quote than the urn shows. Also, if it were one continuous quote, why does it seem so awkwardly spaced? Why not move the last word on line 2 to line 3 or even combine it all down to 4 or 3 total lines. What if this if 5 seperate lines of text we need? Also, for all the previous puzzles, you could solve the entirety of all the puzzles within the realm of the maze of games book. You didn't need to find something that existed outside of the maze (even for the 9 of Jokers, the text makes note that Colleen knew what the phrase was that she needed to decipher the greek letters, even though I as a reader had to look it up since it wasn't written in the book). How could Colleen reasonably be expected to have some random 11 word quote memorized and know to put it in there (Basically if the quotes not in the maze, I would expect it to be something like "To Be or Not to Be", or "Call me Ishmael", something iconic that could plausibly be remembered by her). She even makes a point in saying I doubt I have all the information to process that yet, which seems to indicate she solves this eventually using something she finds later in the maze. Or since there are 11 paragraphs on the page (and 11 words needed for the urn), she couldn't solve it at the time because we somehow extract a word from each paragraph and she needed the page to be be completely written to solve the urn.